SimPL Insights

Why We Verify Everything: The New Reality of Carrier Vetting

Written by Elayna Slocum - Senior Legal Specialist | Jul 8, 2026 8:50:23 PM

There was a time in transportation when a carrier's word and a handshake were enough to build a business relationship. Those days are a distant memory now.

Today's transportation industry faces an unprecedented level of fraud, identity theft, cargo theft, and legal exposure. Freight criminals are becoming increasingly sophisticated, using stolen identities, compromised email accounts, fake insurance certificates, and even cloned carrier profiles to infiltrate the supply chain.

At the same time, courts are placing greater emphasis on a broker's responsibility to exercise reasonable care when selecting the carriers entrusted with their customers' freight.

As a result, one principle has become essential to protecting our customers and our company:

Verify everything

That statement isn't meant to imply that carriers are inherently dishonest. In fact, the vast majority of carriers we work with are hardworking, reputable companies that take great pride in their operations. However, in today's environment, assumptions and shortcuts can have serious consequences.

Freight Fraud Is No Longer Rare

Strategic cargo theft and fraud have become the fastest-growing threats in the industry. Criminals are constantly developing new schemes, including:

  • Impersonating legitimate carriers and brokers
  • Hijacking carrier email accounts
  • Using stolen or falsified insurance documents
  • Double brokering freight to unauthorized carriers
  • Creating shell companies with little or no operating history
  • Manipulating business records to appear legitimate

These schemes can result in stolen freight, significant financial losses, supply chain disruptions, and damaged customer relationships.

And the fraudsters are almost always counting on one thing - someone failing to verify the information they provide.

Why Carrier Vetting Matters More Than Ever

Carrier vetting is often viewed as an administrative hurdle or an inconvenience that slows down the process of booking a load. In reality, it is one of the most important risk management functions in transportation.

Before we entrust a shipment to a carrier, we must ask important questions:

  • Is the carrier operating under active authority?
  • Do they have the appropriate insurance coverage?
  • Is their safety performance acceptable?
  • Are there signs of identity fraud or double brokering?
  • Does their operational history support their representations?
  • Are there any red flags that warrant additional review?

These questions are not asked because we distrust carriers. They are asked because our customers trust us to protect their freight and make informed decisions on their behalf.

The Legal Landscape Has Changed

Recent legal developments have reinforced the importance of exercising reasonable care in carrier selection. Brokers are increasingly expected to demonstrate that they have established processes for evaluating and monitoring the carriers they use. A decision to overlook obvious warning signs or bypass established procedures can create significant exposure when something goes wrong. Good intentions are no substitute for good processes.

Technology Helps, But It Doesn't Replace Judgment

The transportation industry has access to more data than ever before. Technology has significantly improved our ability to identify risk, detect fraud, and monitor carrier performance. However, technology alone is not enough.

Data must be reviewed, analyzed, and, when necessary, questioned. Sometimes the most important risk indicators are not found in a report or dashboard but in inconsistencies, unusual behavior, or information that simply doesn't make sense.

Effective carrier vetting requires both technology and human judgment.

Why We Verify Everything

At our company, verification is not about creating barriers or making it harder for carriers to do business with us.

It is about protecting:

Every verification process exists because someone in this industry has already suffered the consequences of not performing it.

The Bottom Line

The transportation industry is built on relationships and trust. But in today’s transportation landscape, trust should be earned through verification, not assumed. Due diligence is no longer optional—it is essential.

Because when it comes to protecting our customers and their freight, one principle guides every decision we make:

Verify everything.